Skip to content
NHQualityCampaign.orgIndependent nursing home quality resource
Measures & RatingsFor families & professionals

Nursing Home Penalties and Fines on Care Compare Explained

Federal fines and payment denials are penalties CMS imposes when a nursing home has serious or uncorrected health or safety citations. Care Compare lists the fines and payment denials each home received over roughly the last three years. This guide explains what they mean, how big they can be and how to look them up.

Updated 7 min readHow we research
Clinician writing on a patient chart on a clipboard
Photo: Vitaly Gariev (Unsplash License). Credits

What penalties can CMS impose on a nursing home?

Every Medicare- and Medicaid-certified nursing home is inspected by its state survey agency on CMS's behalf. When inspectors find that a home is out of compliance with federal requirements (42 CFR Part 483), the citation is called a deficiency and is graded by scope and severity on an A to L grid. Most deficiencies only require a plan of correction. When a citation is serious, repeated or not corrected in time, CMS can add enforcement remedies. The two that appear on Care Compare are:

  • Civil money penalties (CMPs), or fines. A fine can be imposed once per citation (a "per-instance" CMP) or for each day the home is out of compliance (a "per-day" CMP) until it corrects the problem.
  • Denial of payment for new admissions (DPNA). Medicare and Medicaid stop paying the home for newly admitted residents until it is back in compliance. A DPNA is mandatory if a home is still out of compliance three months after the survey.

Other remedies, such as directed plans of correction, directed in-service training, state monitoring, temporary management and termination from Medicare and Medicaid, do not show up as a separate "penalty" line on Care Compare, but they are listed in CMS enforcement data and often mentioned in inspection reports. Homes with a persistent record of serious problems may also be placed in the Special Focus Facility program.

How much are nursing home fines?

The ranges are set in 42 CFR 488.438 and adjusted every year for inflation under 45 CFR Part 102. CMS's 2025 adjustment table lists these amounts:

Federal civil money penalty ranges for nursing homes, 2025 inflation-adjusted (CMS)
Type of fineWhen it appliesMinimumMaximum
Per day, lower rangeDeficiencies that cause actual harm or have potential for more than minimal harm, without immediate jeopardy$136 a day$8,211 a day
Per day, upper rangeImmediate jeopardy (likely to cause serious injury, harm, impairment or death)$8,351 a day$27,378 a day
Per instanceA single citation, at any level of seriousness that warrants a fine$2,739$27,378

CMS sets the amount using its CMP analytic tool and factors such as severity, history of noncompliance, culpability and the facility's finances. Per-day fines can add up quickly: a home cited for immediate jeopardy that takes two weeks to fix the problem can owe six figures. Under 42 CFR 488.436, a home that does not contest a fine (waives its hearing) gets a 35% reduction; since a 2023 rule change that waiver happens automatically if the home does not request a hearing within 60 days.

How does Care Compare report penalties?

On a nursing home's profile on Medicare Care Compare, the penalties section lists the federal fines (date and dollar amount) and payment denials (start date and length) the home received over roughly the last three years. Medicare.gov describes them simply: penalties may be imposed when a home has a serious health or fire safety citation, or fails to correct a citation for a long time. The same data are in the downloadable "Penalties" file on the CMS Provider Data Catalog.

Penalties do not directly change the star ratings. The health inspection rating already reflects the deficiencies behind them, weighted by scope and severity. That is why a home with a large fine almost always has a low inspection rating as well. For a full walk-through of the profile, see how to read a Care Compare report.

What does a fine or payment denial actually tell you?

Reading the penalty record
What you seeWhat it usually meansWhat to check next
No penalties in 3 yearsNo federal enforcement beyond plans of correction. Good, but not proof of good care.Inspection rating, staffing and recent complaint surveys
One small fine (a few thousand dollars)Often a single per-instance fine for a harm-level or repeat citationWhich F-tag it was and whether it was corrected on revisit
A large fine (tens or hundreds of thousands)Usually immediate jeopardy, actual harm, or a problem left uncorrected for weeksThe inspection report for that date; whether the same tag recurs
Payment denialThe home did not return to compliance on time, or had serious problems on several surveysHow long the denial lasted and whether the home is an SFF or candidate
Several fines across different yearsA pattern rather than a one-off eventOwnership changes, staffing turnover and the abuse icon

How to look up a nursing home's fines

  1. 1
    Find the home
    Search by name or ZIP code on Care Compare or start from our nursing home finder, which pulls the same CMS data.
  2. 2
    Open the penalties section
    Note the date, amount and type of each fine and any payment denial.
  3. 3
    Match it to an inspection
    Open the health inspection report for the date just before the penalty and find the citations graded G or higher (harm) or J, K or L (immediate jeopardy). Our health inspections guide explains the grid.
  4. 4
    Look for repeats
    The same F-tag on two or more surveys is more concerning than a single citation that was fixed.
  5. 5
    Ask the home
    Ask the administrator what happened, what changed and who monitors it now. A clear, specific answer is a good sign.
  6. 6
    Check state sources
    Your state survey agency and long-term care ombudsman can tell you about recent complaints and state actions.

For providers: responding to a CMP

A CMP notice starts several clocks: the plan of correction, the 60-day window to request a hearing before the Departmental Appeals Board, and informal dispute resolution with the state. Facilities that decide not to contest receive the 35% reduction automatically. Whatever the decision, the durable fix is the same: a root cause analysis, a corrective action plan run through QAPI, and evidence that the change held. Our survey readiness checklist and root cause analysis guide help. Keeping staff licences, certificates and training records current in one place, for example with a free credential expiry tracker, removes one common source of citations.

Frequently asked questions

What is a civil money penalty for a nursing home?

A civil money penalty (CMP) is a federal fine CMS imposes on a Medicare- or Medicaid-certified nursing home that is out of compliance with federal requirements. It can be charged once per citation or for each day the problem continues. In 2025 terms, per-day fines range from $136 to $27,378 and per-instance fines from $2,739 to $27,378.

What is a denial of payment for new admissions?

It is a penalty under which Medicare and Medicaid stop paying a nursing home for residents admitted after the denial starts, until the home corrects its deficiencies. Current residents keep their coverage. CMS must impose it if a home remains out of compliance three months after a survey, and may impose it sooner for serious problems.

Where can I see if a nursing home has been fined?

Open the home's profile on Medicare Care Compare and go to the penalties section, which lists federal fines and payment denials from roughly the last three years. The same data are in the CMS Provider Data Catalog. For state fines and licence actions, check your state health department or ask the local long-term care ombudsman.

Should I avoid a nursing home that was fined?

Not automatically. A single small fine that was corrected may matter less than a pattern of harm citations. Look at what the citation was for, how long ago it happened, whether the same problem recurred, and the home's current staffing and inspection results. Repeated large fines or payment denials are a serious warning sign.

Do fines affect a nursing home's star rating?

Not directly. The fines themselves are not part of the Five-Star calculation, but the deficiencies that caused them are counted in the health inspection rating, weighted by scope and severity. That is why homes with large fines usually also have low inspection and overall ratings.

Can a nursing home appeal a fine?

Yes. A facility can request a hearing before an administrative law judge at the HHS Departmental Appeals Board within 60 days of the notice, and can use informal dispute resolution with the state to challenge the underlying citations. If it does not request a hearing, the fine is reduced by 35% under federal rules.

Free, no-obligation help

Get help choosing care or coverage

Talk with a licensed agent about Medicare, Medigap, Medicare Advantage and ways to pay for a nursing home stay. Or call 1-800-MEDIGAP (1-800-633-4427).

Answered by licensed insurance agents, not by Medicare or CMS.

Sources

  1. CMS: LTC, HHA, hospice and CLIA calculation of CMP adjustments, 2025
  2. eCFR: 42 CFR 488.438, Civil money penalties: amount of penalty
  3. eCFR: 42 CFR 488.436, Waiver of hearing and reduction of penalty amount
  4. Medicare.gov Care Compare: nursing home penalties
  5. CMS: Civil Money Penalty Reinvestment Program

Independent resource. NHQualityCampaign.org is an independent educational resource. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by or operated by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), any government agency, or the original Advancing Excellence in America’s Nursing Homes campaign or its sponsors. Historical campaign information is summarized with attribution for educational purposes.