Skip to content
NHQualityCampaign.orgIndependent nursing home quality resource
Measures & RatingsFor families & professionals

The Care Compare Abuse Icon: What It Means and What to Do

The red abuse icon on Care Compare marks a nursing home cited for abuse that harmed a resident, or for repeated abuse citations over about two years. It also caps the home's inspection rating at two stars. Here is how CMS decides, how long it stays and what families should do.

Updated 6 min readHow we research
Two people holding hands across a table for comfort
Photo: Priscilla Du Preez (Unsplash License). Credits

What is the abuse icon on Care Compare?

In October 2019 CMS added an icon (a red circle with an open hand) to nursing home listings to make it easier for the public to spot homes cited for abuse, neglect or exploitation. It was announced in memo QSO-20-01-NH and carried over when Nursing Home Compare became Care Compare in 2020. The icon shows in search results and at the top of the home's profile, next to the star ratings.

What are the criteria for the abuse icon?

According to the September 2026 Five-Star Technical Users' Guide, a home gets the icon if it meets either of these tests:

CMS abuse icon criteria (Five-Star Technical Users' Guide, September 2026)
TestSeverityTime window
1. Harm-level abuse citationScope and severity G or higher (residents actually harmed, or immediate jeopardy)The most recent standard survey, or a complaint or focused infection control survey within the past 12 months
2. Repeat abuse citationsScope and severity D or higher (potential for more than minimal harm)Both (a) the most recent standard survey or a complaint survey in the past 12 months, and (b) the previous standard survey or a complaint survey 13 to 24 months ago

CMS counts as "abuse" any deficiency under three F-tags: F600 (freedom from abuse and neglect, including physical, mental and sexual abuse, physical punishment and neglect by anyone), F602 (misappropriation of a resident's money or belongings) and F603 (involuntary seclusion). Our health inspections guide explains the A to L severity grid.

How does the abuse icon affect star ratings?

A home with the icon has its health inspection rating capped at two stars. Because the overall rating starts from the inspection rating and can rise by at most one star each for strong staffing and quality measures, the best overall rating a home with the icon can have is four stars. In practice most homes with the icon have one or two stars overall.

How long does the abuse icon stay on Care Compare?

There is no fixed term. CMS removes the icon (and the rating cap) at the first monthly website refresh after the home no longer meets either test. In practice:

  • A harm-level citation on a standard survey keeps the icon until the next standard survey replaces it, which is usually 12 to 15 months later, assuming no new abuse citations.
  • A harm-level citation from a complaint survey ages out after 12 months.
  • Repeat citations can keep the icon for two years or longer if each new survey adds another one.

So an icon tells you something serious happened recently. Its absence does not prove a home is free of problems: abuse is under-reported, and some citations are still pending or under appeal when the data are refreshed.

What should families do if a home has the abuse icon?

  1. 1
    Read the citation
    Open the health inspection report and find the F600, F602 or F603 citation. Note what happened, how many residents were affected and the severity letter.
  2. 2
    Ask the home directly
    Ask the administrator what happened, what changed, how staff are now screened and trained, and how residents and families can report concerns without retaliation.
  3. 3
    Talk to the ombudsman
    The long-term care ombudsman knows the home's recent history and can tell you whether problems persist.
  4. 4
    Compare alternatives
    Use the nursing home comparison tool to put this home side by side with two or three others nearby.
  5. 5
    If your relative already lives there
    Visit at different times, get to know staff, attend care plan meetings and learn the warning signs of abuse and poor care.

Is the abuse icon fair to nursing homes?

Provider associations argued when it launched that a single citation, sometimes for a resident-to-resident incident or a reporting lapse, could brand a home for a year or more. Consumer advocates countered that abuse citations are already rare relative to the harm that occurs. Both points are worth bearing in mind: read the citation itself rather than relying on the icon alone. CMS also notes that some Oregon abuse findings are handled by Adult Protective Services and may not appear on Care Compare, so families there should check the state's own records.

For providers: preventing abuse citations

The federal abuse requirements sit in 42 CFR 483.12: screening, training, prevention, identification, investigation, protection and reporting. Surveyors look for written policies covering all seven components, staff who can explain how to report, timely reporting to the state and investigations completed within five working days. Building these into versioned policies, for example with a policy and SOP builder, and reviewing incidents through QAPI helps. Staff stability matters too; see staff stability.

Frequently asked questions

What does the red hand icon mean on Medicare Care Compare?

It is the abuse icon. It means the nursing home was cited for abuse, neglect or exploitation that harmed a resident on its most recent standard inspection or a complaint inspection in the last 12 months, or was cited for abuse with potential for harm in each of the last two years. It also caps the home's inspection rating at two stars.

How long does the abuse icon stay on a nursing home's profile?

Until the home no longer meets CMS's criteria. CMS removes it at the first monthly Care Compare refresh after that happens. A harm-level complaint citation ages out after 12 months; one on a standard survey usually lasts until the next standard survey, typically 12 to 15 months later. New abuse citations can extend it.

Can a nursing home with the abuse icon have a 5-star rating?

No. The icon caps the health inspection rating at two stars. Because the overall rating starts from the inspection rating and can only rise by one star each for staffing and quality measures, the highest overall rating a home with the icon can have is four stars.

What counts as abuse for the Care Compare icon?

CMS counts deficiencies under three federal tags: F600 (abuse and neglect, including physical, mental and sexual abuse and physical punishment), F602 (misappropriation of a resident's money or property) and F603 (involuntary seclusion). Citations under other tags, such as accidents or pressure injuries, do not trigger the icon on their own.

Should I move my parent out of a nursing home with the abuse icon?

Not necessarily, but take it seriously. Read the citation, ask the administrator what changed, talk to the ombudsman and watch closely for warning signs. If your parent is unsafe, unhappy or the problems continue, compare nearby homes and plan a move. Never ignore signs of abuse while you decide.

How do I report nursing home abuse?

Call 911 if someone is in danger. Otherwise report to your state survey agency, which licenses and inspects nursing homes, and to Adult Protective Services or the long-term care ombudsman. You can also tell the administrator in writing. The Eldercare Locator at 1-800-677-1116 can give you local contact numbers.

Free, no-obligation help

Get help choosing care or coverage

Talk with a licensed agent about Medicare, Medigap, Medicare Advantage and ways to pay for a nursing home stay. Or call 1-800-MEDIGAP (1-800-633-4427).

Answered by licensed insurance agents, not by Medicare or CMS.

Sources

  1. CMS: Five-Star Quality Rating System Technical Users' Guide (September 2026)
  2. CMS QSO-20-01-NH: Consumer alerts added to Nursing Home Compare (October 2019)
  3. eCFR: 42 CFR 483.12, Freedom from abuse, neglect and exploitation
  4. Medicare.gov Care Compare
  5. ACL: Eldercare Locator

Independent resource. NHQualityCampaign.org is an independent educational resource. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by or operated by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), any government agency, or the original Advancing Excellence in America’s Nursing Homes campaign or its sponsors. Historical campaign information is summarized with attribution for educational purposes.