Skip to content
NHQualityCampaign.orgIndependent nursing home quality resource
Professional ToolkitFor professionals

Root Cause Analysis in Nursing Homes: 5 Whys, Fishbone, Example

Root cause analysis (RCA) is a team method for finding the system and process failures behind an adverse event so you can prevent it from happening again. This page walks through CMS's seven RCA steps, the 5 Whys and fishbone tools, a PIP charter template and a worked example of a fall with injury.

Updated 7 min readHow we research
Older person gripping a walker handle during a mobility session
Photo: rawpixel (CC0 1.0 (public domain)). Credits

RCA is a core QAPI skill. CMS's free Guidance for Performing Root Cause Analysis (RCA) with Performance Improvement Projects (PIPs) describes it as a structured, facilitated team process to find out what happened, why it happened and what needs to change. CMS notes that using its tools is not mandated and does not by itself ensure compliance. See the QAPI overview for how RCA fits the wider program.

What are the steps of a root cause analysis?

  1. 1
    1. Select the event and gather preliminary information
    Prioritize events with serious harm, events you must investigate by regulation, and "near misses" that could have caused harm. Collect the incident report, statements, photos, policies and any equipment involved.
  2. 2
    2. Charter the team and pick a facilitator
    Leadership appoints a facilitator and team members who know the processes involved. Keep managers to a minimum so frontline staff speak freely.
  3. 3
    3. Describe what happened
    Build a timeline of facts: who, what, when, where. Write the problem statement as what went wrong, not why or how to fix it.
  4. 4
    4. Identify contributing factors
    List the conditions that made the event more likely: staffing, communication, environment, equipment, policies, resident factors.
  5. 5
    5. Identify root causes
    Dig into contributing factors with the 5 Whys or a fishbone until you reach causes that, if removed, would prevent recurrence.
  6. 6
    6. Design and implement changes
    Choose actions that target each root cause, test them with PDSA cycles, and assign owners and dates.
  7. 7
    7. Measure success
    Track a measure on a run chart to confirm the change worked and is sustained.

How do you use the 5 Whys?

Start with the problem statement and ask "why did this happen?" Answer with facts, then ask "why?" of that answer. Repeat until you reach a cause the facility can control, usually by the fourth or fifth why. Stop if answers turn into blame ("because the aide was careless"); ask instead why the system allowed it.

How do you build a fishbone diagram?

Write the problem at the "head" of the fish. Draw bones for categories of causes and brainstorm under each. Common nursing home categories:

Fishbone categories adapted for nursing homes
CategoryQuestions to ask
People (staff)Staffing level, agency use, training, fatigue, consistent assignment
ResidentCognition, mobility, medications, continence, recent changes
Methods (policies and procedures)Was there a policy? Was it clear, current and followed? Could it be followed?
Equipment and suppliesAvailability, maintenance, alarms, lifts, beds, footwear
EnvironmentLighting, flooring, clutter, bathroom layout, noise
CommunicationHandoffs, care plan visibility, family input, practitioner notification

Worked example: root cause analysis of a fall with injury

This is a fictional composite for teaching. Problem statement: At 03:10 on a Tuesday, an 84-year-old long-stay resident with moderate dementia and a history of two falls was found on the bathroom floor of her room and sustained a hip fracture.

Timeline (facts only)
TimeEvent
22:00Evening dose of a new sleep medication given (started four days earlier)
00:30Rounding: resident asleep; bed in low position; call light within reach
01:00–03:00Night CNA covering two halls because of a call-off; agency CNA new to the unit
03:10Resident found on bathroom floor; bed alarm had been turned off after repeated false alarms
03:15Nurse assessment; practitioner and family notified; transfer to hospital

5 Whys:

  1. Why did she fall? She got up alone at night to use the bathroom and lost her balance.
  2. Why did she get up alone? She needed to void and no one was nearby; she does not reliably use the call light.
  3. Why was no one nearby? Night rounds were every two hours and the only experienced CNA was covering two halls.
  4. Why was her toileting need not anticipated? Her care plan did not include a night toileting schedule, although she had voided around 03:00 most nights.
  5. Why was the pattern missed? Night-shift bladder diary data were not reviewed at care plan meetings, and the new sedative was not flagged as a falls risk to the IDT.
Root causes and actions
Root causeAction (stronger to weaker)Owner / measure
No night toileting plan based on voiding patternStandard: review 3-day voiding diary for all residents with prior falls; add scheduled toileting to care planMDS coordinator; % of fallers with toileting plan
New sedative not reviewed for falls riskPharmacy alert for any new sedative-hypnotic in residents with prior falls; prescriber review within 72 hoursConsultant pharmacist; % of alerts reviewed
Alarm fatigue led to alarm being disabledReplace with a low-false-alarm sensor or remove alarm in favor of scheduled rounding; no silent disablingUnit manager; alarm audit
Call-off coverage spread one CNA across two hallsNight call-off protocol with on-call pool; keep agency staff paired with a regular CNADON; % of night shifts at planned staffing

The team then tracks falls with major injury per 1,000 resident-days and the process measures above on run charts. Use the falls log on our tracking tools page, and read more on falls prevention. Falls with injury are also tied to F689, the second most-cited tag in 2025 (see our survey readiness checklist).

PIP charter template

Performance improvement project charter (fill-in)
SectionExample entry for the fall RCA
Project nameNight falls reduction: Maple unit
Problem statementFalls with major injury on Maple occurred at 0.9 per 1,000 resident-days over 12 months, with most between 23:00 and 06:00
Aim (SMART)Reduce night falls on Maple by 50% and falls with major injury to 0.3 per 1,000 resident-days by 30 June 2027
MeasuresOutcome: night falls rate; Process: % of fallers with toileting plan; Balancing: sleep disturbance complaints
ScopeMaple unit, all long-stay residents with a fall in the last 6 months
TeamFacilitator (ADON), 2 night CNAs, night nurse, pharmacist, PT, family member
SponsorAdministrator and DON
TimelineWeekly 30-minute meetings; report to QAA monthly

Store completed RCAs and charters with your incident logs so trends across events become visible. A shared incident log and review template library keeps every unit using the same format. For running the project itself, see our implementation guides, and return to the QI toolkit for more tools.

Frequently asked questions

What is a root cause analysis in a nursing home?

It is a structured team investigation of an adverse event, near miss or complaint that identifies the underlying system and process failures behind it. The goal is to change those systems so the event is less likely to happen again. RCA focuses on processes rather than individual blame and usually leads into a performance improvement project.

What are the 5 Whys in root cause analysis?

The 5 Whys is a questioning technique: state the problem, ask why it happened, then ask why again of each answer until you reach a cause the facility can fix. Five is a guide, not a rule. It works best for fairly simple chains of cause and should rely on facts, not assumptions.

When should a nursing home do a root cause analysis?

Consider an RCA for any event causing serious harm or death, events you are required to investigate, recurring problems shown on tracking data, serious complaints and near misses that could have caused harm. Leadership should set criteria in the QAPI plan so selection is consistent rather than ad hoc.

What is a fishbone diagram used for?

A fishbone, or Ishikawa, diagram organizes possible causes of a problem into categories such as people, residents, methods, equipment, environment and communication. It helps a team brainstorm broadly before narrowing down. It works well for complex problems like falls or pressure injuries where many factors interact.

Does CMS require nursing homes to perform root cause analyses?

QAPI regulations at 42 CFR 483.75 require facilities to take actions aimed at performance improvement and to conduct systematic analysis of problems, including how to identify root causes. CMS provides a free RCA guide but notes that using its specific tool is not mandated. Some states and accrediting bodies set additional requirements.

What makes a strong corrective action after an RCA?

Strong actions change the system so the error is hard to make: redesigning a process, standardizing equipment, adding forcing functions or changing staffing models. Weaker actions rely on memory, such as re-education or new warning signs. Most effective action plans combine at least one strong action with training and a measure to track results.

Sources

  1. CMS Guidance for Performing Root Cause Analysis (RCA) with PIPs
  2. CMS QAPI Five Whys tool
  3. CMS QAPI fishbone diagram tool
  4. CMS PIP Charter Worksheet
  5. 42 CFR 483.75 QAPI (eCFR)

Independent resource. NHQualityCampaign.org is an independent educational resource. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by or operated by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), any government agency, or the original Advancing Excellence in America’s Nursing Homes campaign or its sponsors. Historical campaign information is summarized with attribution for educational purposes.