Why does staff stability matter for quality?
When caregivers leave, residents lose people who know them, remaining staff carry heavier loads, and training investments walk out the door. Research summarized in CMS's Five-Star technical guide associates higher turnover with poorer resident outcomes. The former national campaign's fact sheets made the same points: turnover leads to more turnover, the departure of a director of nursing tends to increase turnover in every nursing category, and turnover is highest in the first months of employment.
Stability also makes other improvements possible. Consistent assignment and person-centered care both depend on a stable team.
How do you calculate staff turnover in a nursing home?
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| CNAs on payroll 1 January | 60 |
| CNAs on payroll 31 December | 64 |
| Average headcount | (60 + 64) / 2 = 62 |
| CNAs who left during the year | 31 |
| Annual turnover | 31 / 62 x 100 = 50% |
| Of the original 60, still employed 31 December | 42 |
| 12-month retention | 42 / 60 x 100 = 70% |
Report both. Turnover can look high because a few positions churn repeatedly while most of the team is stable; retention shows whether the core is holding. Break results down by job type (RN, LPN, CNA), shift, unit and tenure band (under 90 days, 90 days to 1 year, over 1 year). Our staff turnover calculator does the math for you.
- Decide in writing whether you count voluntary and involuntary separations together (most homes do) and whether PRN staff are included.
- Use the same definition every month so trends mean something.
- Calculate monthly and annualize, but judge trends on rolling 12-month figures to smooth seasonal noise.
How does CMS measure turnover on Care Compare?
Since January 2022, Care Compare has displayed three turnover measures built from Payroll-Based Journal (PBJ) data, and since July 2022 they have counted in the staffing star rating. According to the September 2026 Five-Star technical guide:
| Element | CMS specification |
|---|---|
| Measures | Total nurse staff turnover (RNs, LPNs/LVNs, nurse aides); RN turnover; number of administrator departures. |
| Who is counted | Employees and agency staff who work at least 120 hours in a 90-day period, so occasional fill-ins are excluded. |
| What counts as turnover | A gap of at least 90 consecutive days with no hours worked, starting during the measurement year. |
| Formula (nurse measures) | Employment spells ending in turnover / eligible employment spells (maximum 100%). |
| Data window | Six consecutive quarters of PBJ data to produce one annual measure. |
| Points in staffing rating | Total nurse turnover up to 50 points; RN turnover up to 50; administrator turnover up to 30 (0 departures = 30, 1 = 25, 2 or more = 10). Maximum staffing score is 380. |
| Exclusions and penalties | Homes with fewer than five eligible nurses are excluded from the nurse measures; missing or erroneous PBJ data earns the lowest score. |
Total nursing staff turnover is also one of the eight measures in the Skilled Nursing Facility Value-Based Purchasing (SNF VBP) Program for FY 2027, so it now affects Medicare payment as well as star ratings. Because CMS identifies turnover from gaps in PBJ hours, accurate and on-time PBJ submissions matter as much as actual retention.
What about staffing minimums?
The 2024 federal minimum staffing standards (3.48 total nurse hours per resident day and 24/7 RN coverage) were struck down in court in 2025 and repealed by a CMS interim final rule effective 2 February 2026. Existing requirements remain: sufficient staff to meet residents' needs (F725), an RN on site 8 consecutive hours a day, 7 days a week, a full-time director of nursing, and an annual facility assessment (42 CFR 483.71) that should include a staffing plan focused on recruiting and retaining direct care staff.
How can nursing homes reduce turnover?
- 1Stabilize leadership firstAdministrator and DON turnover ripple through every department. Invest in their support, succession planning and realistic workloads.
- 2Fix the first 90 daysStructured orientation, a named peer mentor, check-ins at 1, 30, 60 and 90 days, and protected time before full assignments. Track turnover in the under-90-day band separately.
- 3Run stay interviews, not just exit interviewsAsk current staff what keeps them, what might make them leave and what one thing would help. Act on themes and tell staff what changed.
- 4Make schedules predictableConsistent assignment, fair weekend rotation, self-scheduling within rules, and minimal mandatory overtime.
- 5Recognize and grow peopleCareer ladders (CNA to medication aide to LPN), tuition support, peer recognition and visible thank-yous from leaders.
- 6Measure monthly in QAPIPlot turnover, retention and vacancy by role; review with the QAPI committee and run PDSA cycles on the biggest driver.
Standard onboarding runbooks, check-in forms and stay-interview templates make the first 90 days consistent across hiring managers; a free back-office template library is one option for keeping them versioned.
Monthly staff stability dashboard
- Rolling 12-month turnover by role (RN, LPN, CNA) and by unit
- 12-month retention of staff employed a year ago
- Turnover of staff in their first 90 days
- Vacancies and agency hours as a share of total nursing hours
- Administrator and DON tenure
- Your latest Care Compare turnover values and staffing rating
See the quality improvement overview for how this fits a QAPI program, and the professional toolkit for templates.
Frequently asked questions
How do you calculate staff turnover in a nursing home?
Divide the number of employees who left during the period by the average number of employees in that period, then multiply by 100. The average is usually the headcount at the start plus the headcount at the end, divided by two. Calculate by job type and track a rolling 12-month figure.
What is a good staff turnover rate for a nursing home?
There is no official target. Nursing home turnover is high nationally, so the most useful comparison is your own trend and your state and national figures on Care Compare. CMS awards more staffing-rating points to homes in lower turnover deciles, which gives a practical benchmark.
How does CMS measure nursing home staff turnover?
CMS uses Payroll-Based Journal data. Staff who worked at least 120 hours in a 90-day period are eligible, and a person counts as turnover after 90 consecutive days with no hours worked. Care Compare shows total nurse turnover, RN turnover and administrator departures.
Does staff turnover affect a nursing home's star rating?
Yes. Since July 2022 the staffing star rating has included three turnover measures. Total nurse and RN turnover are each worth up to 50 points and administrator turnover up to 30, out of 380 total staffing points. Missing or invalid payroll data earns the lowest score.
What is the difference between turnover and retention?
Turnover counts how many people left relative to average headcount. Retention counts how many of the people you had at the start are still there at the end. A home can have high turnover in a few churning roles yet good retention of its core team, so track both.
Why is nursing home staff turnover so high?
Common drivers include heavy workloads, short staffing, low pay relative to other jobs, unpredictable schedules, weak orientation and leadership instability. Turnover is concentrated in the first months of employment, which is why onboarding and mentoring are high-yield fixes.
Sources
- CMS: Five-Star Quality Rating System Technical Users’ Guide (September 2026)
- Medicare.gov Care Compare: staffing for nursing homes
- CMS: Skilled Nursing Facility Value-Based Purchasing Program
- Advancing Excellence leadership fact sheet: Improve Staff Stability (2012, archived)
- eCFR: 42 CFR 483.71 Facility assessment
Independent resource. NHQualityCampaign.org is an independent educational resource. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by or operated by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), any government agency, or the original Advancing Excellence in America’s Nursing Homes campaign or its sponsors. Historical campaign information is summarized with attribution for educational purposes.
Related reading
Staff turnover calculatorAnnual staff turnover is the number of employees who left in 12 months divided by your average headcount…
Consistent assignmentConsistent assignment means the same CNAs and nurses care for the same residents on most shifts.
Nurse StaffingNursing home staffing is measured in nurse hours per resident day (HPRD), reported to CMS through the…
QAPIQAPI is the data-driven quality program every certified nursing home must run under 42 CFR 483.75.
Quality ImprovementNursing home quality improvement is the ongoing, data-driven work of making resident care safer and daily…
Person-centered carePerson-centered care means a resident's own preferences and goals shape daily routines, meals, activities and…
