Why does nurse staffing matter so much?
Nurses and nurse aides deliver almost all hands-on care: turning residents to prevent pressure injuries, helping them to the toilet, noticing a change in condition before it becomes a hospital transfer. CMS's own Five-Star Technical Users' Guide cites research linking staffing levels and staff turnover with resident outcomes. That is why staffing is one of the three domains in the Five-Star rating, and why total nurse staffing and turnover now also affect Medicare payments through SNF Value-Based Purchasing.
What is Payroll-Based Journal (PBJ) data?
Since 2016, nursing homes have had to submit daily staffing hours for each employee and contractor, drawn from payroll and agency records, through CMS's Payroll-Based Journal system. Data are due 45 days after the end of each quarter. Because PBJ is based on hours actually paid, it is far more reliable than the old self-reported two-week snapshots.
PBJ counts employees and agency or contract staff. It does not count private-duty aides paid by families, hospice staff or feeding assistants. CMS excludes implausible data, such as zero nursing hours or more than 12 total nurse HPRD, and audits homes; a failed audit means a one-star staffing rating.
What does hours per resident day (HPRD) mean?
HPRD is the total hours worked by a staff type in a day, divided by the number of residents that day. If a 100-resident home logs 350 nursing hours across all shifts in 24 hours, its total nurse staffing is 3.5 HPRD. That does not mean each resident gets 3.5 hours of one-to-one care; it is a measure of staff capacity, including time spent on documentation and medication passes.
| Staff type | Who is included | Typical role |
|---|---|---|
| Registered nurse (RN) | Director of nursing, RNs with administrative duties, staff RNs (codes 5–7) | Assessment, care planning, clinical judgment, supervision |
| Licensed practical/vocational nurse (LPN/LVN) | LPNs with administrative duties and staff LPNs (codes 8–9) | Medication passes, treatments, monitoring |
| Nurse aide | Certified nurse aides, aides in training, medication aides (codes 10–12) | Bathing, dressing, toileting, eating, mobility |
The staffing figures CMS uses for ratings are case-mix adjusted: a home whose residents need more care (based on PDPM nursing groups from the MDS) is expected to staff more. Care Compare shows both the reported hours and the adjusted hours.
How are staff turnover and weekend staffing measured?
- Turnover. CMS identifies anyone who worked at least 120 hours over 90 days and then had a gap of 90 or more consecutive days with no hours. Total nurse turnover and RN turnover are the share of eligible staff who left over a year; administrator turnover is a simple count of departures.
- Weekend staffing. Total nurse HPRD is calculated separately for Saturdays and Sundays, when staffing often drops. It is worth up to 50 of the 380 staffing points.
- RN gaps. A home reporting four or more days in a quarter with no RN hours while residents were present gets a one-star staffing rating automatically.
Providers can estimate their own figures with our staff turnover calculator and find retention strategies in staff stability and consistent assignment.
What happened to the federal minimum staffing rule?
In May 2024 CMS finalized the first federal nurse staffing minimums for nursing homes. The rule never fully took effect. Here is the timeline:
- 110 May 2024: final rule publishedIt required 3.48 total nurse HPRD, including 0.55 RN HPRD and 2.45 nurse aide HPRD, plus an RN on site 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, phased in over several years. It also strengthened the facility assessment requirement.
- 27 April 2025: Texas court rulingA federal district court in Texas vacated the HPRD minimums and the 24/7 RN requirement in a lawsuit brought by the American Health Care Association and others.
- 318 June 2025: Iowa court rulingA federal district court in Iowa, in a case brought by a coalition of states, also vacated the staffing minimums and the 24/7 RN requirement, leaving the facility assessment provisions in place.
- 4July 2025: congressional moratoriumSection 71111 of Public Law 119-21 barred CMS from implementing or enforcing the 2024 standards until after 30 September 2034.
- 53 December 2025: repeal publishedCMS issued an interim final rule removing the minimums and reinstating the pre-2024 nurse staffing requirements, effective 2 February 2026.
What federal staffing rules still apply in 2026?
Under 42 CFR 483.35 and related rules, certified nursing homes must:
- Have sufficient nursing staff, with the right competencies, to meet each resident's needs as identified in assessments and care plans.
- Have a registered nurse on duty at least 8 consecutive hours a day, 7 days a week (waivers are possible in limited circumstances).
- Employ a full-time director of nursing who is an RN.
- Post daily nurse staffing information where residents and visitors can see it.
- Complete and keep current a facility assessment (42 CFR 483.71) that determines the staff and resources needed for the resident population. This requirement survived the repeal.
Do states have minimum staffing requirements?
Yes. Many states set their own floors, which apply alongside federal rules. Requirements differ in what counts and how they are enforced. Three examples:
| State | Minimum | Source |
|---|---|---|
| New York | 3.5 hours of care per resident per day, including at least 2.2 hours by certified nurse aides and 1.1 hours by licensed nurses | Public Health Law § 2895-b |
| California | 3.5 direct care service hours per patient day, including at least 2.4 certified nurse assistant hours | 22 CCR § 72329.2 (Health & Safety Code § 1276.65) |
| Massachusetts | 3.58 hours of care per resident per day, of which at least 0.508 must be RN care | 105 CMR 150.007 |
State rules change; check your state health department, or start from our state-by-state nursing home guides.
How can families check a nursing home's staffing?
- 1Open the staffing section on Care CompareFind the home on Care Compare and compare its total nurse, RN and weekend HPRD with the state and national averages shown beside them.
- 2Check turnoverHigh nurse turnover, or two or more administrators leaving in a year, often signals instability. Ask what the home is doing about it.
- 3Read the posted staffing sheetFederal rules require daily posting of nurse staffing. Compare a weekday with a weekend.
- 4Ask direct questionsHow many residents does each aide care for on day, evening and night shifts? How much agency staff do you use? Do the same aides usually care for the same residents? Our tour questions list has more.
- 5Watch and listenVisit at mealtimes and in the evening. Long call-light waits and residents left in bed late are practical signs of short staffing; see warning signs of poor care.
Frequently asked questions
What is the federal minimum staffing requirement for nursing homes?
As of 2026 there is no federal hours-per-resident-day minimum. The 2024 rule requiring 3.48 total nurse HPRD and a 24/7 RN was vacated by courts in 2025 and repealed effective 2 February 2026. Homes must still have sufficient staff, an RN on duty 8 consecutive hours a day, 7 days a week, and a full-time RN director of nursing.
What does HPRD mean in a nursing home?
HPRD stands for hours per resident day: total hours worked by nursing staff in a day divided by the number of residents. A 100-resident home with 350 nursing hours in a day has 3.5 total nurse HPRD. Care Compare reports total, RN, LPN, nurse aide and weekend HPRD for each certified home.
What is a good staffing level for a nursing home?
There is no single federal benchmark. The repealed 2024 rule set 3.48 total nurse HPRD as a floor, and states such as New York and California require 3.5. A practical test is to compare a home's case-mix adjusted HPRD with its state and national averages on Care Compare and to check its turnover.
Why was the nursing home staffing mandate repealed?
Two federal district courts, in Texas in April 2025 and Iowa in June 2025, ruled that CMS lacked authority for the HPRD minimums and 24/7 RN requirement. Congress then barred enforcement until after September 2034. CMS issued an interim final rule in December 2025 removing the standards, effective 2 February 2026.
How is nursing home staff turnover calculated?
CMS uses PBJ data. Staff who worked at least 120 hours in 90 days are eligible; anyone who then goes 90 or more consecutive days without working is counted as having left. Turnover is the percentage of eligible staff who left over 12 months, reported separately for all nursing staff and for RNs.
Where can I see how many nurses a nursing home has?
Care Compare's staffing section shows each home's average nurse hours per resident per day, broken down by RN, LPN and nurse aide, plus weekend staffing and turnover. Homes must also post daily nurse staffing on site. The underlying PBJ data are downloadable from CMS's Provider Data Catalog.
Get help choosing care or coverage
Talk with a licensed agent about Medicare, Medigap, Medicare Advantage and ways to pay for a nursing home stay. Or call 1-800-MEDIGAP (1-800-633-4427).
Sources
- Federal Register: Repeal of Minimum Staffing Standards for Long-Term Care Facilities (3 Dec 2025)
- LeadingAge: Interim final rule repeals nursing home staffing standard
- AHA: Iowa district court vacates CMS minimum nurse staffing requirements (June 2025)
- eCFR: 42 CFR 483.35 Nursing services
- CMS: Five-Star Technical Users' Guide (staffing domain), September 2026
- CMS: Payroll-Based Journal staffing data submission
Independent resource. NHQualityCampaign.org is an independent educational resource. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by or operated by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), any government agency, or the original Advancing Excellence in America’s Nursing Homes campaign or its sponsors. Historical campaign information is summarized with attribution for educational purposes.
Related reading
Five-Star RatingsCMS builds a nursing home's overall star rating from its health inspection rating, then adds or subtracts…
Using Care CompareMedicare's Care Compare lets you look up any certified nursing home and compare its star ratings, inspection…
Staff stabilityStaff stability is how well a nursing home keeps its caregivers, measured by turnover and retention rates.
Staff turnover calculatorAnnual staff turnover is the number of employees who left in 12 months divided by your average headcount…
Tour questions checklistOn a nursing home tour, ask about staffing, turnover, inspections, medical and dementia care, food…
Quality MeasuresNursing home quality measures are standard rates, built from MDS assessments and Medicare claims, that track…
