Skip to content
NHQualityCampaign.orgIndependent nursing home quality resource
Nursing home report

Otterbein Portage Valley in Pemberville, OH: Ratings, Staffing and Inspections

Otterbein Portage Valley is a 50-bed medicare and medicaid at 20311 Pemberville Rd, Pemberville, OH 43450. CMS rates it 4 of 5 stars overall: above average.

Data as of November 18, 2026 · Source: CMS Care Compare (Nursing Home Provider Information, released 2026-10-01) · CCN 365571

Part of a CCRC
Overall
4 of 5 stars, Above averageAbove average
Health inspections
3 of 5 stars, About averageAbout average
Staffing
3 of 5 stars, About averageAbout average
Quality measures
5 of 5 stars, Much above averageMuch above average

How CMS calculates star ratings · How to read a Care Compare report

Staffing

MeasureThis homeOhio averageU.S. average
Total nurse hours per resident per day3.343.713.9
RN hours per resident per day0.720.640.69
Nursing staff turnover49%49%45%
Average residents per day46.6Certified beds: 50

Reported staffing comes from payroll data (PBJ). Higher nurse hours and lower turnover are generally better. See nursing home staffing explained.

Health inspection citations (27)

1 of 27 citations were at the actual-harm or immediate-jeopardy level. Most recent survey: July 29, 2026.

  • F760: Ensure that residents are free from significant medication errors.
    July 29, 2026 · Complaint inspection · Severity D: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F580: Immediately tell the resident, the resident's doctor, and a family member of situations (injury/decline/room, etc.) that affect the resident.
    April 15, 2026 · Complaint inspection · Severity D: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F812: Procure food from sources approved or considered satisfactory and store, prepare, distribute and serve food in accordance with professional standards.
    April 15, 2026 · Complaint inspection · Severity D: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F686: Provide appropriate pressure ulcer care and prevent new ulcers from developing.
    June 18, 2025 · Standard inspection · Severity D: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F695: Provide safe and appropriate respiratory care for a resident when needed.
    June 18, 2025 · Standard inspection · Severity D: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F697: Provide safe, appropriate pain management for a resident who requires such services.
    June 18, 2025 · Complaint inspection · Severity D: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F755: Provide pharmaceutical services to meet the needs of each resident and employ or obtain the services of a licensed pharmacist.
    June 18, 2025 · Complaint inspection · Severity D: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F880: Provide and implement an infection prevention and control program.
    June 18, 2025 · Standard inspection · Severity D: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F684: Provide appropriate treatment and care according to orders, resident’s preferences and goals.
    March 4, 2025 · Complaint inspection · Severity D: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F689: Ensure that a nursing home area is free from accident hazards and provides adequate supervision to prevent accidents.
    March 4, 2025 · Complaint inspection · Severity D: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F842: Safeguard resident-identifiable information and/or maintain medical records on each resident that are in accordance with accepted professional standards.
    March 4, 2025 · Complaint inspection · Severity D: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F551: Give the resident's representative the ability to exercise the resident's rights.
    January 23, 2025 · Complaint inspection · Severity D: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F550: Honor the resident's right to a dignified existence, self-determination, communication, and to exercise his or her rights.
    September 10, 2024 · Complaint inspection · Severity D: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F607: Develop and implement policies and procedures to prevent abuse, neglect, and theft.
    September 10, 2024 · Complaint inspection · Severity C: Potential for minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has plan of correction
  • F677: Provide care and assistance to perform activities of daily living for any resident who is unable.
    July 23, 2024 · Complaint inspection · Severity D: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F759: Ensure medication error rates are not 5 percent or greater.
    May 30, 2024 · Complaint inspection · Severity D: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F760: Ensure that residents are free from significant medication errors.
    May 30, 2024 · Complaint inspection · Severity D: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F686: Provide appropriate pressure ulcer care and prevent new ulcers from developing.
    November 28, 2022 · Standard inspection · Severity G: Actual harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F919: Make sure that a working call system is available in each resident's bathroom and bathing area.
    November 28, 2022 · Standard inspection · Severity E: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F558: Reasonably accommodate the needs and preferences of each resident.
    November 28, 2022 · Standard inspection · Severity D: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F561: Honor the resident's right to and the facility must promote and facilitate resident self-determination through support of resident choice.
    November 28, 2022 · Standard inspection · Severity D: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F582: Give residents notice of Medicaid/Medicare coverage and potential liability for services not covered.
    November 28, 2022 · Standard inspection · Severity D: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F677: Provide care and assistance to perform activities of daily living for any resident who is unable.
    November 28, 2022 · Standard inspection · Severity D: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F684: Provide appropriate treatment and care according to orders, resident’s preferences and goals.
    November 28, 2022 · Standard inspection · Severity D: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction
  • F883: Develop and implement policies and procedures for flu and pneumonia vaccinations.
    November 28, 2022 · Standard inspection · Severity D: Potential for more than minimal harm · Deficient, Provider has date of correction

See all citations on Care Compare

How inspections and severity codes work

Penalties and fines

CMS lists no fines or payment denials in the past three years.

Ownership

Ownership type: Non profit - Corporation.

  • OTTERBEIN LSC, LLC · 5% or greater direct ownership interest · 100% · since 01/01/2016
  • OTTERBEIN HOME · 5% or greater indirect ownership interest · 100% · since 12/01/2021
  • BARBEE, DANIEL · managing control - governing body · since 12/01/2021
  • BENEDICT, JUDY · managing control - governing body · since 01/01/2024
  • BOWLUS, MARILYN · managing control - governing body · since 01/01/2014
  • GODFREY, MIKE · managing control - governing body · since 01/01/2024
  • HINDS, NORRIS · managing control - governing body · since 04/01/2021
  • KYLLO, THOMAS · managing control - governing body · since 01/01/2015
  • LOAR, TARA · managing control - governing body · since 01/01/2025
  • MCKIBBIN, KATIE · managing control - governing body · since 01/01/2023
  • POWELL, ANGIE · corporate director · since 11/24/2014
  • STEPHENSON, JOHN · corporate director · since 08/09/1982
Call (419) 833-7000Official Care Compare pageMap & directionsCompare with others

Nearby nursing homes rated 4+ stars

All nursing homes in Ohio

Frequently asked questions

What is Otterbein Portage Valley's star rating?

CMS rates Otterbein Portage Valley 4 out of 5 stars overall (above average). Health inspections: 3, staffing: 3, quality measures: 5 stars.

How many deficiencies did Otterbein Portage Valley receive?

The CMS health deficiencies data lists 27 citations from recent inspection cycles, most recently on July 29, 2026, including 1 at the actual-harm or immediate-jeopardy level.

Has Otterbein Portage Valley been fined?

CMS lists no fines or payment denials for Otterbein Portage Valley in the past three years.

Who owns Otterbein Portage Valley?

Otterbein Portage Valley is listed as Non profit - Corporation, with 53 owners or managing parties reported to CMS.

Free, no-obligation help

Get help choosing care or coverage

Talk with a licensed agent about Medicare, Medigap, Medicare Advantage and ways to pay for a nursing home stay. Or call 1-800-MEDIGAP (1-800-633-4427).

Answered by licensed insurance agents, not by Medicare or CMS.

Sources: CMS Care Compare Provider Data Catalog: Provider Information (4pq5-n9py), Health Deficiencies (r5ix-sfxw), Penalties (g6vv-u9sr) and Ownership (y2hd-n93e). Data as of November 18, 2026 · Source: CMS Care Compare (Nursing Home Provider Information, released 2026-10-01). This page is an independent summary; check the official Care Compare page before deciding.

Medicare disclaimer. We do not offer every plan available in your area. Any information we provide is limited to those plans we do offer in your area. Please contact Medicare.gov or 1-800-MEDICARE (TTY 1-877-486-2048), 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, to get information on all of your options.

NHQualityCampaign.org is not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program. Calls to 1-800-MEDIGAP (1-800-633-4427) are answered by licensed insurance agents, not by Medicare or CMS.

Independent resource. NHQualityCampaign.org is an independent educational resource. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by or operated by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), any government agency, or the original Advancing Excellence in America’s Nursing Homes campaign or its sponsors. Historical campaign information is summarized with attribution for educational purposes.