Skip to content
NHQualityCampaign.orgIndependent nursing home quality resource
MedigapFor families

Switching Medigap Plans: When You Can Change and How

You can apply to switch Medigap plans at any time, but outside your open enrollment period most states let insurers ask health questions and turn you down. You can switch without underwriting if you have a guaranteed issue right or live in a state with a birthday, anniversary or year-round switching rule.

Updated 4 min readHow we research
Two people holding hands across a table for comfort
Photo: Priscilla Du Preez (Unsplash License). Credits

Can you change your Medigap plan at any time?

You can apply any time, but approval is not guaranteed. Under federal law you only have a right to switch during your six-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period or in a guaranteed issue situation. Otherwise, the new insurer can use medical underwriting unless your state adds protections, such as a birthday rule, Missouri's anniversary rule, or year-round guaranteed issue in Connecticut and New York.

Ways to switch Medigap plans
RouteUnderwriting?What you can switch to
Medigap Open Enrollment PeriodNoAny plan sold in your state
Federal guaranteed issue situationNoUsually A, B, C*, D, F* or G
State birthday or anniversary ruleNoUsually equal or lesser benefits; rules vary
Year-round state rights (e.g. CT, NY)NoAny plan sold
Any other timeUsually yesAny plan the insurer will sell you

*C and F only if you were eligible for Medicare before 1 January 2020.

How to switch Medigap plans safely

  1. 1
    Check your rights
    See Medigap rules by state and ask your SHIP whether you qualify for a protected switch.
  2. 2
    Compare like for like
    Compare benefits and premiums, including rating method and rate history. See Medigap costs.
  3. 3
    Apply for the new policy
    On the application you will promise to cancel the old policy. Answer health questions truthfully if asked.
  4. 4
    Wait for approval
    Do not cancel the old policy yet.
  5. 5
    Use the 30-day free look
    Once the new policy starts, you have 30 days to decide. You pay both premiums for that month.
  6. 6
    Cancel the old policy
    Ask your old insurer how to end coverage so there is no gap. Once cancelled, you cannot get it back.

Will a new policy cover pre-existing conditions?

If you have had your current Medigap policy for more than six months and the new one has the same benefits, the new insurer cannot impose a waiting period for pre-existing conditions. If you have had it for less than six months, the new insurer may make you wait up to six months, minus the months you already had coverage. If the new policy includes a benefit your old one did not, you may have to wait up to six months for that benefit.

Common switches and what to watch

  • Plan F to Plan G: you give up only the Part B deductible ($283 in 2026). Worth it if the premium saving is larger. See Plan G vs Plan F.
  • Plan G to Plan N: lower premium, but copays and no excess charge coverage. See Plan G vs Plan N.
  • Same plan, new insurer: often the simplest saving; many birthday rules allow it.
  • Medigap to Medicare Advantage: easy to do in the fall, but returning later may need underwriting unless a trial right applies.
  • Pre-2010 or discontinued plans (E, H, I, J): you can keep them; if you switch, you cannot return.

This independent guide on choosing a new Medigap plan and this Medicare Supplement explainer can help you compare. If you want a licensed agent to check whether you can switch without health questions, call the 1-800-MEDIGAP helpline. Back to the Medicare Supplement plans guide.

Frequently asked questions

Can I switch Medigap plans without medical underwriting?

Yes, in certain cases: during your Medigap Open Enrollment Period, in a federal guaranteed issue situation, under a state birthday or anniversary rule, or in states with year-round rights such as Connecticut and New York. Otherwise, most insurers can ask health questions and decline you.

What is the Medigap free look period?

When you switch, you have 30 days after the new policy starts to decide whether to keep it. You pay premiums for both policies during that month. Do not cancel your old policy until you are sure you want the new one.

Can I switch Medigap insurance companies but keep the same plan?

Yes, if the new insurer accepts you. Outside protected windows, it may use underwriting. Several birthday-rule states, such as Kentucky, Indiana and Virginia, specifically protect same-letter switches to a different insurer. If you have had your policy over six months, the new insurer cannot impose a pre-existing condition wait.

Can I switch Medigap plans if I have health problems?

Possibly. If you have a guaranteed issue right or a state switching right, the insurer cannot turn you down or charge more for your health. Otherwise, an insurer may decline you. Keep your current policy until any new policy is approved.

How often can I change Medigap plans?

There is no federal limit on how often you can apply. Protected switches depend on state law, usually once a year around your birthday or policy anniversary (every two years in West Virginia). In Connecticut and New York, guaranteed issue is available year-round.

1-800-MEDIGAP helpline

Talk to a licensed Medicare agent

Compare Medicare Supplement and Medicare Advantage options and understand what Medicare covers. Or call 1-800-MEDIGAP (1-800-633-4427).

Answered by licensed insurance agents, not by Medicare or CMS.

Sources

  1. Medicare.gov / CMS and NAIC: Choosing a Medigap Policy (2026)
  2. KFF: Medigap guaranteed issue requirements, federal and state rules (Oct 2026)
  3. NAIC: State Medigap rules, birthday rule and coverage under 65 (as of 11 May 2026)
  4. NAIC: State insurance department directory
  5. SHIP National Technical Assistance Center: find your State Health Insurance Assistance Program

Medicare disclaimer. We do not offer every plan available in your area. Any information we provide is limited to those plans we do offer in your area. Please contact Medicare.gov or 1-800-MEDICARE (TTY 1-877-486-2048), 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, to get information on all of your options.

NHQualityCampaign.org is not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program. Calls to 1-800-MEDIGAP (1-800-633-4427) are answered by licensed insurance agents, not by Medicare or CMS.

Independent resource. NHQualityCampaign.org is an independent educational resource. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by or operated by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), any government agency, or the original Advancing Excellence in America’s Nursing Homes campaign or its sponsors. Historical campaign information is summarized with attribution for educational purposes.