Skip to content
NHQualityCampaign.orgIndependent nursing home quality resource
Medical AlertsFor families

How to Choose a Medical Alert System: A Family Checklist

Choose a medical alert system by matching it to where the person spends time, whether they need fall detection, how well they hear and use technology, and contract terms you can live with. This checklist covers the questions to ask before you sign.

Updated 4 min readHow we research
Care worker helping two older residents with a table activity
Photo: Age Cymru (Unsplash License). Credits

Step 1: Start with the person, not the product

  • Where do they spend time? Mostly at home suits an in-home unit; driving, walking or errands alone suits a mobile GPS device.
  • Fall risk: previous falls, dizziness, fainting, Parkinson's or stroke history point toward fall detection.
  • Hearing: can they hear the operator through a small pendant speaker? If not, an in-home base unit with a loud speaker may work better.
  • Memory: people with dementia may forget to press or charge a device; simplicity and fall detection matter more.
  • Willingness: a device that sits in a drawer helps no one. Involve the person in choosing.

Step 2: Match the device type

Matching needs to device types
If the person…Consider
Rarely leaves homeIn-home base unit with pendant or wristband; add wall buttons in bathroom
Goes out aloneMobile GPS pendant with two-way voice
Is tech-comfortable and wears a watchSmartwatch with SOS and fall detection, ideally with 24/7 monitoring
Has dementia or may wanderSimple device with GPS location and fall detection; discuss with care team
Has significant hearing lossBase unit with loud speaker; check whether text or app alerts reach family
Lives with a spouse who also needs coveragePlan that allows a second button at low cost

Step 3: Check the technical basics

  1. Network: which cellular carrier does it use? Test signal in the home, including bedroom and bathroom. Older 3G devices stopped working when carriers shut down 3G networks in 2022.
  2. Range: for in-home units, how far from the base does the button work? Test the yard and mailbox.
  3. Waterproofing: it must be safe to wear in the shower.
  4. Battery: how long between charges for mobile devices? Does the base unit have backup power during outages?
  5. Speaker and microphone: can the user hear and be heard from across a room?
  6. Testing: how do you run a test call, and how often should you?

Step 4: Ask about the monitoring center

  • Is the center operated by the company or outsourced? Where is it?
  • Is it listed or certified by an independent body (for example, UL or TMA Five Diamond)?
  • What is the average time to answer an alarm?
  • Are operators trained in emergency response, and is there language support?
  • Can the center see the user's medical notes, medications and preferred hospital?
  • Will it call family first or 911 first, and can you set that order?

Step 5: Read the contract

  • Monthly price, add-on prices and any equipment or activation fee.
  • Contract length and early termination fee.
  • Cancellation if the user moves to a nursing home, enters hospice or dies.
  • Equipment return requirements and charges for lost devices.
  • Trial period and price-lock terms.

Our medical alert system costs page explains how to compare total cost.

Step 6: Set it up well

  1. 1
    Fill in the emergency profile
    Medical conditions, medications, allergies, doctor, preferred hospital, and responders in order.
  2. 2
    Plan for entry
    A lockbox with a key lets responders get in without breaking the door.
  3. 3
    Practice
    Do a test call together. Practice canceling a false alarm.
  4. 4
    Build habits
    Charge mobile devices at the same time each day. Test monthly.
  5. 5
    Review after any change
    Update contacts after a hospital stay, a move or a new diagnosis.

When a medical alert is not enough

If falls are frequent, or the person cannot be safely alone, a device is no longer sufficient. Consider in-home care, adult day care or a move to assisted living or a nursing home. Our care navigator helps families think through options, and the care types comparison explains each setting. For fall prevention, see falls prevention.

Back to the medical alert systems hub. Also see fall detection explained.

Frequently asked questions

Should I choose a monitored or unmonitored medical alert?

Monitored systems connect to a 24/7 call center that can stay on the line and coordinate help, which suits people who live alone or have health conditions. Unmonitored devices call family or friends and have no monthly fee, but depend on someone answering. Many families of frailer adults choose monitored service.

What should I look for in a medical alert system?

Match the device to where the person spends time, whether they need fall detection, their hearing and tech comfort, and whether they will wear it. Check cellular coverage, waterproofing, battery life and speaker volume. Ask about the monitoring center's response time and certification, and read the contract terms.

Which is better, an in-home or mobile medical alert?

In-home systems are cheaper and suit people who rarely leave home. Mobile GPS devices work anywhere with cellular signal and suit active adults, but need daily charging. Some people use both: a base unit at home and a mobile device for outings.

What is the best medical alert system for someone with dementia?

Look for simplicity, automatic fall detection, GPS location and a monitoring center that can see care instructions. Devices that are hard to remove or need little charging help. Discuss with the care team, because a device is not a substitute for supervision when someone is unsafe alone.

How fast do medical alert companies respond?

Response times vary by company. Ask for the average time to answer an alarm and whether the monitoring center is certified by an independent body. Test it yourself during the trial period by placing a test call.

Free quote

Get a quote from a licensed agent

Ask about long-term care, final expense, dental, vision and hearing coverage options available in your state. Or call 1-800-MEDIGAP (1-800-633-4427).

Answered by licensed insurance agents, not by Medicare or CMS.

Sources

  1. FCC: Plan ahead for phase-out of 3G cellular networks
  2. CDC: STEADI, older adult fall prevention
  3. NIA: Falls and falls prevention
  4. Eldercare Locator (ACL)

Independent resource. NHQualityCampaign.org is an independent educational resource. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by or operated by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), any government agency, or the original Advancing Excellence in America’s Nursing Homes campaign or its sponsors. Historical campaign information is summarized with attribution for educational purposes.