Skip to content
NHQualityCampaign.orgIndependent nursing home quality resource
CompareFor families

Compare Nursing Homes Side by Side: Ratings and Staffing

Compare two to four nursing homes side by side using CMS data: star ratings, staff hours and turnover, inspection citations, penalties and the abuse icon. Add homes below, then use our guide to the differences that matter and the questions to ask.

Updated 4 min readHow we research
Calm sitting room with two armchairs and a plant
Photo: Leuchtturm Entertainment (Unsplash License). Credits

How to compare nursing homes in 5 steps

  1. 1
    Build a list
    Find Medicare- and Medicaid-certified homes near the person or near the family members who will visit most, using the nursing home finder (for example nursing homes in Texas). Ask the hospital discharge planner and your doctor for suggestions.
  2. 2
    Filter on the essentials
    Keep homes that have a bed of the type you need (short-term rehab, long-term, dementia unit), accept your payer (Medicare, your Medicare Advantage plan, Medicaid) and are reachable for visits.
  3. 3
    Compare two to four side by side
    Add them to the comparison tool above and look across the rows rather than at one number.
  4. 4
    Visit the top two or three
    Go at different times, including a mealtime or weekend, using our tour questions.
  5. 5
    Check with others
    Ask the long-term care ombudsman about recent complaints, and talk to residents and families you meet.

Which differences matter most?

What to compare and why
Row in the comparisonWhy it mattersA meaningful difference
Health inspection ratingBased on on-site surveys; starting point for the overall ratingTwo or more stars apart, or any harm-level (G+) citations
Abuse icon, SFF statusSignals recent serious harm or a persistent record of problemsAny home with either deserves extra scrutiny
Total nurse hours per resident dayMore hands for care, toileting, meals and response to call lightsRoughly half an hour a day or more
RN hours per resident dayClinical assessment, catching problems earlyLarge gaps, especially at weekends
Staff turnoverStable staff know residents; high turnover often goes with lower quality10 percentage points or more
Quality measures (short or long stay)Outcomes for residents like yoursMeasures far worse than the state average
Penalties (3 years)Fines and payment denials follow serious or uncorrected problemsRepeated or six-figure fines; any payment denial
OwnershipRecent sales and owners with poor records can predict declineChange of owner in the past year or two

Short-term rehab vs long-term care: compare different things

For rehab after a hospital stay, focus on short-stay measures (rehospitalization, emergency visits, functional improvement at discharge), therapy availability seven days a week and discharge to the community. See short-stay measures and, if more intensive therapy is needed, compare with an inpatient rehab facility.

For a long-term move, focus on long-stay measures (falls with injury, pressure ulcers, antipsychotic use, hospitalizations), staffing stability, the dementia program and whether the home accepts Medicaid if savings may run out. See long-stay measures.

Questions to ask every home you compare

  • How many residents does each aide care for on day, evening and night shifts? Who covers weekends?
  • Do you use agency staff? How long have the director of nursing and administrator been here?
  • Can you explain your most recent inspection and what you changed afterwards?
  • Are you in network for our Medicare Advantage plan? Do you accept Medicaid, and is there a Medicaid bed if we need one later?
  • How do you prevent falls and pressure injuries? How do you handle a resident's change in condition at night?
  • What is your approach to dementia and to antipsychotic medicines?
  • How are families involved in care plan meetings?
  • What is included in the daily rate, and what is extra?

Still deciding between a nursing home and another setting? See types of senior care compared. To estimate costs, use the cost of care calculator. If you would like help shortlisting homes, use the call box on this page to talk to a care advisor.

Frequently asked questions

How do I compare nursing homes?

Start with Medicare Care Compare data: overall and health inspection ratings, nurse and RN staffing hours, staff turnover, quality measures, penalties and icons. Put two to four homes side by side, visit the best two or three at different times of day, and ask the long-term care ombudsman about recent complaints before deciding.

What is the most important thing to look for in a nursing home?

Consistent, adequate staffing and a clean recent inspection record are the strongest data signals. On a visit, look for staff who know residents by name, call lights answered quickly, residents who are clean and engaged, and leaders who answer questions about problems openly.

Is a 5-star nursing home always better than a 3-star home?

Not always. Ratings are relative within each state and can change month to month. A three-star home with strong staffing and no serious citations may suit your family better than a five-star home far away or without the services you need. Use stars to narrow the list, not to decide.

Where does the nursing home comparison data come from?

The comparison uses public CMS data published on Medicare Care Compare and the CMS Provider Data Catalog: Five-Star ratings, Payroll-Based Journal staffing data, inspection results, penalties and ownership. Data are refreshed monthly by CMS, but some sources lag by months.

How many nursing homes should I visit?

Visit at least two or three after narrowing your list with the data. If possible, go back to your top choice a second time at a different time of day, such as a weekend or mealtime, to see how care differs when managers are not around.

Free, no-obligation help

Get help choosing care or coverage

Talk with a licensed agent about Medicare, Medigap, Medicare Advantage and ways to pay for a nursing home stay. Or call 1-800-MEDIGAP (1-800-633-4427).

Answered by licensed insurance agents, not by Medicare or CMS.

Sources

  1. Medicare.gov Care Compare
  2. CMS Provider Data Catalog: Nursing homes
  3. CMS: Five-Star Quality Rating System Technical Users' Guide (September 2026)
  4. Medicare.gov: Your guide to choosing a nursing home

Independent resource. NHQualityCampaign.org is an independent educational resource. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by or operated by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), any government agency, or the original Advancing Excellence in America’s Nursing Homes campaign or its sponsors. Historical campaign information is summarized with attribution for educational purposes.